Important News! Afluencer becomes part of→ Learn More

Good vs Bad Followers

Blog Image

July 30, 2020

4 min read

Author Image

Author

Nicole P. Dunford

Best Influencer Marketplace

Global Influencer Database

Brand Partnerships

All-in-one Platform

BRAND SIGN UPFOR CREATORS

One of the most important metrics brands use to apprise influencers they’re considering working with is their follower number. However, the number itself isn’t a good indicator of whether a partnership will help the brand reach its goals. When analyzing an influencer’s following it’s important to make the distinction between good and bad followers. It’s impossible for all the followers that an account has to be extremely engaging and beneficial. However, this doesn’t mean that we should only take the total number at face value without looking into the general quality of the followers an influencer has.

Illustrated follower comment bubble showing 1k user comments

Good Influencer Followers

Good followers are what every influencer strives to have, as they are the selling point a brand will look at when considering a collaboration.

A good follower will have three main qualities:

1. They Are Active

An active follower who uses their account on a regular basis and spends time on the app is much more likely to see a post than someone who rarely logs on.

2. They Are Engaged

Good Followers | Engagement - Comments, Likes, Follows

A follower who is engaged will interact with the influencer’s content by liking, commenting on, and sharing their posts. This shows that the follower has an interest in what the influencer posts and will look for their content.

3. They Have a Small Following Number

A person who follows 200 accounts and one who follows 2000 are not the same. Good followers are those who have curated their feed and they only follow a limited amount of people as this will increase the likelihood of that person seeing your influencer’s post.

Bad Influencer Followers

On the other hand, a large number of bad followers can be a sign that your collaboration with an influencer may not achieve the results you expect.

There are several things that can help you determine if a follower is not the kind you’re looking for:

1. They’re inactive

This is a pretty obvious one. If a follower doesn’t use their account anymore, there is no chance of them ever seeing your sponsored post.

2. They lack engagement

Illustration depicting poor engagement - broken heart

Followers who are too passive on social media, who never engage with the content on their feed by liking, commenting, or sharing, and who don’t follow channels are not your target. A follower who is inactive brings very little to an influencer’s table.

3. They follow too many accounts

On the flip side, someone who follows thousands of accounts has an extremely cluttered feed, overwhelmed with tons of content from all sides. Even though this user spends plenty of time on the platform, the odds of them seeing your post are much lower.

4. They use follow-for-follow

Text illustration - Hashtags follow for follow

The follow-for-follow strategy is an unfortunate reality of social media. These users will only follow influencer channels in the hopes that they will follow them back. Luckily, they can be quickly screened out by taking a look at their hashtags where they will usually use #followforfollow #follow4follow #f4f #followme and other variants.

5. Fake (purchased) followers

Illustration of influencer buying followers

Fake followers, the bane of the influencer world. Purchased followers are not interested in the channel they follow, and they won’t be interested in your product. In fact, many of these fake followers aren’t even real people. They are bots. Their purpose is to artificially increase the follower number without any substance behind it.

→ Here’s the right way to grow your Instagram followers

Frequently Asked Questions

<details class="ih-faq"><summary>How can I tell if an influencer has fake followers?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Look for signs like unusual engagement patterns, bot-like comments, and accounts with no profile picture or bio. Check if they use follow-for-follow hashtags like #f4f or #followme. Afluencer&#x27;s analytics tools can help identify suspicious follower activity and verify account authenticity before partnerships.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>What percentage of followers should be &#x27;good&#x27; for influencer marketing?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">While the article doesn&#x27;t specify an exact percentage, quality matters more than quantity. Focus on engagement rate, follower activity, and relevance to your brand rather than a specific ratio. Even influencers with smaller followings can deliver strong results if their audience is genuinely engaged and aligned with your target market.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>Why do influencers have fake followers?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Some influencers purchase fake followers to artificially inflate their follower count and appear more influential to potential brand partners. These bots aren&#x27;t real people and won&#x27;t engage with content or convert to customers. Brands should verify authenticity before collaborating to ensure genuine audience reach and campaign success.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>How do follower count and engagement rate relate?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">A high follower count doesn&#x27;t guarantee engagement. Good followers actively like, comment, and share content, while bad followers remain passive. An influencer with 10,000 engaged followers may deliver better results than one with 100,000 inactive or fake followers. Always examine engagement metrics alongside follower numbers.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>Should brands only work with influencers who follow few accounts?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Influencers with curated feeds—following fewer accounts—typically have more focused, engaged audiences. However, quality of followers matters more than strict follower limits. The key is finding influencers whose followers are active, engaged, and genuinely interested in their niche, regardless of exact follow counts.</div></details>

More Influencer Marketing Insights

Explore more guides and playbooks on finding the right creators and growing your brand with influencer marketing.

Best Influencer Marketplace

Unlock the full potential of your brand through our creator marketplace & all-in-one influencer platform.

LEARN MORE