Important News! Afluencer becomes part of→ Learn More

Major Red Flags that the Influencer you’re working with is a Quack

Blog Image

March 18, 2020

3 min read

Author Image

Author

Nicole P. Dunford

Influencer Red Flags to look out for

It’s almost like a rule in the business world that wherever money starts flowing, crackpots show up who try to pass themselves off as experts when they really don’t know anything at all.

It’s the same case with the social media influencer industry. Every day red flags go up and people come up to us saying that they signed up with a fake influencer. And now they want us to fix the mess. While digital marketing and digital business promotion are incredibly successful, it’s still nascent with respect to regulatory intervention that can prevent fraud.

It’s also one of the reasons why the demand for fake Instagram followers continues to rise over the years.

For these reasons, it’s better if you keep a lookout for yourself before someone scams you out of a fair bit of money without any results to show for it. Considering the growing importance and the sums of money flowing into the industry, it’s probably safe to assume that there are at least a few thousand dollars of yours tied into your marketing budget.

Before you hand out this money to someone, look out for these red flags of potential influencer fraudsters.

Shady Engagement Rates

The typical Instagram influencer has a likes to followers ratio of 1:3, i.e. one for every three followers. Some influencers have higher ratios but that’s because they have relatively fewer followers—it’s more of a mathematical difference than an actual indicator of the demand for their content.

It’s a red flag for sure if your influencer has insanely high engagement rates. They make you think that their content is brilliant. But it’s just because they’ve bought the following rather than generating it organically.

Go through your influencer’s feeds to see what their engagement rates look like—if they’re consistently high, then either they’re the Messiahs of social media or they’re faking it.

Online Influencers Just Need Their Phones

They Don’t Have Enough Content

Another big red flag is if you find Instagram or Facebook influencer accounts that have a huge following but very little content. That’s a fake account straight off the bat. How can someone generate this large a following but have nothing for these followers to engage with?

Check What Kind of Engagement They’re Getting

If you find influencer accounts with really weird comments on their posts that make no sense, this is a clear red flag. They’re more than likely working with fake followers. These comments are actually bots posting these comments to boost their engagement figures. Whenever you approach an influencer for your marketing, make sure to give their posts a cursory glance. Check to see if the interactions look genuine or not.

Find Authentic Social Media Influencers at Afluencer!

No influencer red flags here! Afluencer is an online platform that helps businesses find some of the best social media influencers to improve marketing outcomes. We serve as a midway between influencers and businesses to connect and collaborate for mutually beneficial business agreements.

Get in touch with us today for more information on our services.

Frequently Asked Questions

<details class="ih-faq"><summary>How can I check if an influencer bought their followers?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Analyze their engagement rates and compare them to the industry standard of 1:3 (likes to followers). Unusually high ratios suggest purchased followers. Also examine their comments for bot-like or nonsensical interactions, which indicate fake engagement. Platforms like Afluencer help verify authentic influencers.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>What is a normal engagement rate for Instagram influencers?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">A typical Instagram influencer has a likes-to-followers ratio of approximately 1:3, meaning one like for every three followers. Some accounts with fewer followers may show higher ratios, but this is mathematically expected rather than indicative of superior content quality.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>Why do some influencers have huge followings but no posts?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Accounts with large followings but minimal content are typically fake. It&#x27;s nearly impossible to generate genuine followers without providing engaging content for them to interact with. This is a major red flag indicating purchased followers rather than organic growth.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>How do I spot bot comments on influencer posts?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Look for comments that seem irrelevant, nonsensical, or generic across multiple posts. Authentic engagement involves meaningful conversations related to the content. Bot comments lack context and appear repetitively, signaling fake followers artificially inflating engagement metrics.</div></details><details class="ih-faq"><summary>Where can I find verified and authentic influencers for my brand?</summary><div class="ih-faq-a">Afluencer is an influencer marketplace that connects businesses with vetted, authentic social media influencers. The platform serves as a trusted intermediary to facilitate genuine collaborations and help you avoid working with fraudulent accounts or fake influencers.</div></details>

More Influencer Marketing Insights

Explore more guides and playbooks on finding the right creators and growing your brand with influencer marketing.

Best Influencer Marketplace

Unlock the full potential of your brand through our creator marketplace & all-in-one influencer platform.

LEARN MORE